I notice that when a user logs in, the new_rewrite method seems to record the first access but then shows nothing about where the user navigated to afterwards. When I login with a user (non admin) account and then logoff and view access log...it shows all my page navigation and access. Is this because I am logging in from the same IP that the admin account is using ? Is there an option to track user's movements otherwise ?
Are the users accessing protected content (ie. downloads, etc) post install or what is the content you are protecting. For single signon type solutions (ie. Wordpress) aMember will not track each page movement. For realtime tracking of your visitors throughout your site, whether they are protected via aMember or not, I recommend taking a look at GetClicky.